La Paz, Bolivia: Where the Streets Are Paved with Coca Leaves
Action
For me, the highlight of our time in La Paz, Bolivia was our visit to the Coca Museum.
The exhibits at the museum explained the various ways the coca plant has been used, and we learned the following. The coca plant has been cultivated for thousands of years by indigenous people in the Andean region, which includes Ecuador, Peru and Bolivia. Coca is used in religious ceremonies and cultural celebrations. Incas applied coca leaves to anesthetize patients undergoing brain surgeries. Coca is still used for medicinal purposes, as I learned when a guide recommended that I drink a tea with coca leaves to soothe my upset stomach.
Coca is also a stimulant. The Spanish who operated the silver mines of Bolivia encouraged the indigenous people toiling in the mines to chew coca leaves, to maintain the energy to work long hours. Miners in Potosi continue to chew leaves to suppress their appetite and increase their energy. The museum also contained an exhibit on Coca Cola, which still uses coca leaves as a flavoring.
While walking around looking at the exhibits, Josh and I chewed handfuls of coca leaves. They tasted bitter, and after a few minutes our tongues felt numb. I felt more alert afterwards, but less jittery than after drinking a couple mugs of coffee. Coca also effects how the body processes oxygen, making it easier to breathe at high altitudes. We also purchased some coca candy at the museum, which had the same effect as chewing a handful of leaves without making our tongues green.
Cultivating coca is legal in two areas of Bolivia, but outlawed in the rest of the country. Its sale and consumption is legal everywhere, so it’s not uncommon to see leaves for sale in bulk on the street (The going price is about $2 US per half kilo.):
When we took a bus through Chapare, a region where coca cultivation is legal, our bus was stopped at two checkpoints and members of the Bolivian military searched for the precursor chemicals that are used to manufacture cocaine. Because coca leaves are legal, I didn’t have to worry about the drug-sniffing dogs finding my coca candy.
The sign reads, "Bienvenidos al Chapare/Estamos en lucha contra las drogas/unete a nosotros...denuncia al que la tiene” (Welcome to Chapare/We are in a fight against drugs/Unite with us...denounce those who have them)
Just down the street from the checkpoint, we saw a sign informing us that the road was being paved with funds from the US Agency for International Development (USAID).
Reflection
What does the Bolivian military and US foreign spending have to do with a plant used by indigenous people for thousands of years? This could have been just a light essay describing what I learned about how another culture uses a particular plant, if it weren’t for the United States’ War on Drugs. As part of the war on drugs, the US Drug Enforcement Administration sprays coca plantations in Latin America with pesticides, which destroy other crops and poison people living nearby. The US is now trying to encourage cocaleros (farmers who grow coca) to switch to other crops. Unfortunately, the alternative crops provided by the US, such as banana and pineapple trees, take longer to bear fruit and aren’t as profitable. Cocaleros have been fighting the forced and coerced eradication of their crops and livelihoods, leading to sometimes violent confrontations with their government. Nonethess, the US government is spending hundreds of millions of dollars in aid to Bolivia with the goal of eradicating the coca fields.
Question
Should coca leaves be treated differently from tobacco leaves and coffee beans? How would you feel if coca leaves were sold in your corner store? Who should decide how coca leaves are regulated?


4 Comments:
At 4:33 PM, Jen said…
This reminds me of the issues with hemp/marijuana in this country - even though they are different! Sounds like coca itself has legit reasons to be grown, and it sounds a lot like caffeine in its natural form.
At 3:24 PM, lernerm said…
Wow, this could be a long one. I'm glad you had the experience. Coca is indeed like marijuana, in that if used in the form you describe, it is relatively harmless (except to the teeth). Alas, it can be transformed into cocaine, which is of course quite abusable (just a wine can be more easily abused in the distilled form of hard liquor). The problem lies not in the drug, but in the way it is used and the people who are misusing it. Sugar can can be chewed, but people who do that rarely have cavities. Sugar in the form of cotton candy however is another thing. Tobacco on the other hand is bad in any form - chewed, smoked, whatever. What makes this so amusing is that the US government actually supports tobacco use (still gives it to soldiers), while fighting an unwinnable war against les harmful drugs. Spraying the crops has never proven to be an effective tool - Nixon tried it with marijuana in 1969 in Mexico, and the last I looked, it's still available. What spraying does accommplish is to punish the poor farmers, and makes for good publicity. How would I feel if coca was sold in my corner store? Well, it was - at least it was about 90 years ago, and I don't recall it harming anyone. It was found as an ingredient in wines as well. We have replaced it with caffeine, which is similar in nature, but more addictive in the form in which we use it (Starbucks). When you guys have the time, if you're interested, you can read either The Natural Mind, by Andrew Weil, and/or LIcit and Illlicit Drugs, by Brecher (Consumer Reports book on drugs-really). I guess this is enough for now.
At 12:44 PM, Swilkes! said…
Alma Guillermoprieto, a Mexican journalist who writes occasionally for the New Yorker, wrote a series of amazing articles about the cocaine trade in Columbia, which of course is the biggest hub for U.S.-bound cocaine and is the biggest focus of the U.S. DEA & "War on Drugs." They're in one of her two essay books which you can find on amazon, I forget which one. Guillermoprieto, who is very critical of the "War on Drugs," independently came to the conclusion that it is north american cocaine consumption--that is, U.S. consumers who are buying coke--that are ultimately to blame for the coke trade in S. America and its effects on societies and economies there. I know that sounds like a War on Drugs take on things, but think about it: just as people who choose to buy stuff at Wal-Mart are supporting an economic system that keeps disadvantaged people down; or just as people who buy Folgers or Starbucks or whatever are supporting exploitation of coffee plantation workers; so are coke users supporting the Columbian paramilitaries, exploitative drug lords, suppression of farm unions, and so on. Don't think for a minute that the coca grower who sells his harvest to a cocaine cartel is getting a good deal, or helping his family out of poverty. He's barely keeping alive.
Obviously, you're talking about something very different. And I do think it's possible to keep coca leaves legal while controlling cocaine. Legal coca leaf producers, of course, are just as susceptible to falling into exploitative practices, like with coffee or cocoa, but since coca is already such a sensitive issue, I can imagine a "fair trade" system could easily be set up by S. American governments for legal coca growing. I suppose the same is true for cocaine production, or any drug production, but the appeal is so great and the greed so irresistible--cf. the tobacco industry!
At 7:39 PM, Renate said…
Sara,
I haven’t been dilligent about updating my list of books I’ve read (see thebluesquare.org) or else I’d chastise you for not recognizing that I’ve already read The Heart that Bleeds by Alma Guillermoprieto. :) Josh and I bought the book in Oaxaca and have been reading the essays she wrote about the countries we’re visiting as we go.
I agree that if the US were serious about its War on Drugs it would do more to stop drug consumption. Instead, the government produces tv ads that are laughably ineffective and school curriculums that are use scare tactics rather than honest presentation of the consequences of drug use. At the World Social Forum, I attended a panel on drugs in Latin America. The panelists from Bolivia, Colombia, Argentina and The Netherlands agreed that the US war on drugs in Latin America was just the latest pretext for exerting control in the region. I agree.
As for fair trade, I came up with the idea of fair trade drugs a few months ago. Care to go into business with me certifying illicit substances as fair trade? “We certify that this narcotic was cultivated, refined and sold by pacifist, democratically run co-operatives of narco-trafficers…”
--Renate
Post a Comment
<< Home